466 Comments
User's avatar
Boom's avatar

Can't argue with anything you said about F1. Ricciardo needs to leave, and Sargent as well.

Funny you should mention IQ, since Mr. Leyland used aggregate numbers from Israel and India to tell me how Indians as a whole are inferior.

I have another subtle point about the IQ test, the MAKERS of the test did not intend it to be used as a indicator of suitability, or to cast a linear curve the way people interpret it. Don't know if that was in Taleb's article (DNR), but just throwing it out there.

Jack Baruth's avatar

The difficulty with using IQ to shit on Indians is that, just by bell curve and population mechanics/numbers, there are gonna be a LOT more 130IQ Indians that 130IQ Israelis. The same is true of China, about whom the Russians used to say, "If you could machine-gun a million a day, you'd have three years' work ahead of you."

Boom's avatar

A fact I tried pointing out, and failed before being berated further.

Sir Morris Leyland's avatar

I literally DID THE MATH to show that there would be SOME outliers compatible with Western norms and how the SUBSTANTIALLY lower mean interacts with 4x higher population. 4x population only means 4x as many competent people if the means are similar.

Indian Supremacists need to also explain:

* GDP/capita (compared to, say, Vietnam which was communist until 1990)

* Olympic medals (compared to wee Ireland)

* PISA scores (72/74 in 2009, before dropping out)

* The fact that Indian nationals will do almost ANYTHING to escape India

Sir Morris Leyland's avatar

I don't recall ever mentioning Israel (but I suppose it is possible):

>>> import statistics

>>> india = statistics.NormalDist(mu=76, sigma=15)

>>> round(100*(1 - india.cdf(100)), 2)

5.48

>>> round(100*(1 - india.cdf(115)), 2)

0.47

If these numbers are correct, around than 5% of Indians can compete for a 100 IQ job, and less than 0.5% for a 115 IQ job.

If the top 10% of Indians are already integrated into the global economy, the maximum IQ of those "waiting in the wings" to take over a Western job if WFH persists is:

>>> round(india.inv_cdf(0.90))

95

...

So 10% of Indians are CURRENTLY integrated into the global economy, the marginal Indian worker who is NOT ALREADY in the global economy (90th percentile in India) falls between the state AVERAGE of #49 Louisiana and #50 Mississippi.

https://www.inc.com/bill-murphy-jr/we-compared-average-iq-score-in-all-50-states-results-are-eye-opening.html

Donkey Konger's avatar

All these debates come down to an issue of "what percentage of [people X] are smart? what percent are crooks? What percent are kind, open people who can assimilate into judeo-christian values?

It's difficult to estimate the proportions, since good data are hard to come by (and most likely illegal to attest to in print in the US!) That said, the anecdotes don't always paint a pretty picture.

Speaking of anecdotes, the ones from this book https://tinyurl.com/3hvk8zwa

Contained in this twitter thread are HILARIOUS. https://tinyurl.com/3mn7hyj9

(The guy in question in the book still maintains his innocence--impressive chutzpah)

Jeff Madson's avatar

The fact that Liam Lawson is watching this year while Dan Ric, Sargent, and Stroll drive really highlights the fact that driving talent is far from the only consideration F1 teams have when hiring their drivers.

Sherman McCoy's avatar

Lance Stroll has an absolute ironclad right to drive in Formula 1, given his father poured tens of millions of dollars into his junior career, funded his seat at Williams, rescued the Force India team from administration, and invested hundreds of millions into the “Aston Martin” team.

Lance can race F1 until he’s 50 if his father is still willing to fund it.

One could make an argument that Max should be looking at Aston Martin for 2026, or more likely 2027 (if the Red Bull Powertrains effort goes poorly):

Honda engine; Aramco fuel and oil (outside budget cap I believe); Aramco’s ability and willingness to pay Max (he could probably get $250MM / year). If they can lure Adrian Newey over it would make sense.

Jeff Madson's avatar

I would have less of an issue with Stroll if F1 wasn't effectively a closed shop. I believe every team voted against Andretti joining.

Now I'm not saying Team Andretti would be any good, but there would be two more drivers jobs available.

Chuck S's avatar

This 100 percent. And could Andretti do any worse than Sauber or Alpine? And you can imagine the team could afford more than 2 chassis and wouldn't bite its nails every time a driver crashed.

Peter Collins's avatar

Adrian Newey being worth much more than any driver! Have you read his book?

John Van Stry's avatar

One of the biggest problems with 'IQ' is that being too far above the mean is almost as bad as being just as far below. Because the world is made for the mean and the further you get from that, the harder certain things can get. Language and communication being key among them.

Take the phrase 'Drive it like you stole it'. It has two distinct meanings, right?

Now you begin to see the problem.

Sir Morris Leyland's avatar

I know one very smart woman who is often very annoyed. The other smart people I know of both genders seem mostly be very successful and happy. I think that having PhD's from good schools has helped most of them to get good jobs that don't bore them (to Jack's observation that often midwits are better at jobs than the highly intelligent).

Harry's avatar

I have said before, having intelligence above a certain threshold is indistinguishable from mental illness.

Ronnie Schreiber's avatar

I think it was Oliver Sacks who said that people who have outsized abilities in intelligence or art often show minor symptoms of major mental illnesses.

Donkey Konger's avatar

It would be nice to have data on IQ versus mental issues. Gotta wonder what that correlation factor is

Speed's avatar

wait what do you mean it has two different meanings

Speed's avatar

Go fast as hell? really not sure what else it could mean because ive only ever heard it in that context

Adam 12's avatar

Excellent example of language having two meanings depending on which end of the spectrum you are on. At one end you may actually be confused if you don’t have context.

My problem is if I “Drive it like I stole it.” I am still getting caught by the cops or passed on the cart track. Know your limitations and stay out of the left lane of there is faster traffic is what I have to do.

Sherman McCoy's avatar

I missed the relevant discussion on Sunday.

I am having difficulty understanding why you are obsessed with what other people think of Indians, particularly those who might criticize in any way or have a view on “castes” that doesn’t align with yours.

The same could be said for posters who are obsessed with Israel and believe that anyone who dares criticize Israel(is) is a petty, jealous, Jew-hating antisemite.

Jack Baruth's avatar

He's Indian!

No doubt he doesn't want to pay money to read people who just rant about his countrymen -- even if he disagrees with them.

I'd stand idly by while New York City got dropped into a woodchipper -- but if I moved to Germany and some people were always ragging on the USA, I can guarantee you I'd work up some patriotism.

Boom's avatar

I'm not even patriotic. Some of the ridiculous tropes that get trotted out on every opportunity get to be grating..

There are many things wrong culturally with people from the subcontinent, but raw intelligence, or the lack there of is not an obvious one..

Sherman McCoy's avatar

To be clear - I have no problem with India or its exports (i.e., Indians).

Most of the ones I personally know are smart, hard-working, ambitious, clever, etc … but don’t take themselves too seriously.

Sir Morris Leyland's avatar

You don't just post in self-defense. You often make triumphant "obvious" and "common sense" posts that Indians are better than Europeans and Euro-Americans in every meaningful respect; that therefore displacement is natural, obvious, just, and rightfully will only accelerate; and that anyone who objects to this glorious process should probably be ashamed of himself.

When challenged with counterexamples, you dismiss them as anecdotes.

When challenged with statistics, you dismiss the statistics (or, today, the concept of IQ testing itself).

Attempting to characterize legitimate data as "ridiculous tropes" doesn't change the truth of the ideas presented.

Ronnie Schreiber's avatar

A very smart man once gave me some advice about arguing with internet randos: "It doesn't earn you a dime, does it?"

I had a splendid time watching the eclipse with my son, daughter-in-law and grandkids at their friend's place in Cleveland. Showed the kids how to make a pinhole camera to watch the eclipse. Totality was cosmically amazing. Took home some pulled beef from Mendel's KC BBQ. Everyone made it home safely. Life is good.

Speed's avatar

man

but what if arguing with randos could be turned into a profession

Dan's avatar

Then you'd be working for one of the lefty PACs that spam 4chan with low effort posts

soberD's avatar

I don't value IQ, judge

Well how do you compare yourself to other golfers?

By height

silentsod's avatar

Hope everyone is excited for King of the Baggers at COTA!

And some other races, too. I think it's European?

0020's avatar

Intuitive improvisation is the secret of genius per Max Zorin. Yet he goes out of his airship and tries to whack some limey hanging off some suspension bridge, and gets himself killed instead.

You, Jack, are correct.

Jack Baruth's avatar

It was BAD intuitive improvisation!

Sherman McCoy's avatar

One of my absolute favorite Bond movies.

The sight of AARP-aged Roger Moore clomping up the stairs at Le Tour Eiffel in pursuit of May Day after a delightful lunch at Restaurant Jules Verne really sets the tone.

Keith's avatar

I don’t think any tests measure spatial intelligence aside from the drivers test.

I do think drawing stems from spatial intelligence.

There was no test or grade that would indicate that I could design and solve problems at 3x the rate of my peers, and that I could also work at 2x the speed of my mechanics.

I think spatial intelligence is tied to testosterone in a way that nerds and study Asian NPCs really don’t want to acknowledge.

Jack Baruth's avatar

Ah, but why am I such a great driver, and have the temper control of a chimpanzee, when I can't draw, then? :)

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 10, 2024
Comment deleted
Donkey Konger's avatar

Doubt it did, but if that scene in the show "The Gentlemen" used authentic paintings, he wasn't as bad as people say.

Edit: his work is not great not terrible.

https://duckduckgo.com/?q=hitler+paintings

John Van Stry's avatar

Drawing is a skill that takes practice, just like any other skill.

Art, even more so - though having a certain amount of inborn talent will help.

Ronnie Schreiber's avatar

A friend who has played and taught guitar professionally once said, "There's no such thing as talent. It's just technique and practice."

"What about improvisational solos?"

"Oh, I was just talking about playing. Soloing, writing songs, that takes talent."

Knowing how to draw would help me in a lot of things that I do so I asked another friend, who did commercial art and taught art and illustration at the collegiate level, how to learn how to draw. He said to start drawing 30 minutes a day. "What about technical stuff like perspective?" "Oh, that you can learn in minutes, but you can only learn how to draw by drawing."

Interestingly, when people ask me about become writers, I pretty much tell them the same thing. Start writing and eventually you'll find your voice. Oh, and read Strunk & White and once you're good at following their rules you can start to break them.

John Van Stry's avatar

Yeah, I pretty much tell people the same thing, you have to keep doing it to learn how to do it well. I don't tell them about grammar books though. As I've mentioned before, it's pretty much a waste of time. After all there are I think 4 major grammar books and they agree on almost nothing? English grammar is a complete bitch that changes it's clothes, makeup, and shoes, like every other minute.

Just make it entertaining and understandable and you'll do okay.

Ice Age's avatar

Why can't ENGINEERS draw?

They're supposed to be building the future, or at least bridges and airplanes, and they can't pull a coherent image off a piece of paper with a pencil.

JasonS's avatar

I resemble that remark!

In reality, for me, I've spent too much time on a computer.

I used to have less than decent handwriting but it wasn't terrible. I would struggle today to write a legible paragraph.

When I had to draw on graph paper for math or engineering, it wasn't bad. Today its terrible. I struggled last week just just to put a state diagram on a white board. It's all about practice.

sgeffe's avatar

My writing is so terrible that people have said I should have been a doctor. My reply is that I don’t have the patients for it!

I’m here all week—try the Caesar Salad!

Speed's avatar

bro im trying

ive only taken one class of technical drawing and apparently nobody uses pencil anymore

Ice Age's avatar

"The hardest part of any project is WANTING TO DO IT. Get that out of the way and everything else falls into place by itself."

"Don't try to be better than everyone else. Just try to be better than you were yesterday."

Two of the best pieces of wisdom I ever heard.

Chairworthiness's avatar

Because we only have to draw one bird and label it "Bird (typ.)". Or better yet just use a keynote and a legend that says "bird (see sheet C702 for bird detail)" and paste in the standard detail from your bird vendor.

Ice Age's avatar

"See Ref. 25-788-A-Ver. 6K on DWG5623-7790-F, Rev J for currently-approved 'BIRD.' Not for common distribution outside of Design Department. Penalties apply."

CLN's avatar

If they are good engineers, then they can draw, or at least sketch out the idea. If they can’t draw/sketch, then they should do something else.

Ronnie Schreiber's avatar

When I'm designing something, I might make a crude sketch or two, certainly take some measurements, but then I just start cutting wood or using CAD etc.

John Van Stry's avatar

I can draft pretty well freehand. Better if I use a few basic tools.

Ask the guys giving you the bad drawings if they took any drafting classes or not.

I know it was a requirement when I got my degree, and I'm a EE

Thomas Hank's avatar

I draw extremely well with a an excellent mechanical intellect…probably why I gravitated towards Industrial Design.

Thomas Hank's avatar

This fucking iPhone makes me sound like a short bus parole with the spelling and word interjecting however. I’m now refusing to have to visit the physical site to edit.

Speed's avatar

because you get faster when youre mad

duh

S2kChris's avatar

I’m too dum to know what spatial intelligence means but it sounds something like the ASTB? Jack you might want to learn that acronym based on your son’s intended path.

Keith's avatar

I was going to suggest that a pilots license, captains license, or competition license would be strong indicators.

jc's avatar

Good equipment operators have excellent spatial awareness. Some of the operators at the customer sites I go to can thread a needle with twin 20ft containers

Keith's avatar

One of the most painful things I’ve witnessed were the forklift drivers at Cat’s Seguin engine plant. And there are a lot of forklifts there.

Sir Morris Leyland's avatar

WAIS includes at least Block Design and probably other visual-spatial subtests

Most evaluations include the Rey–Osterrieth complex figure

AFTQ includes at least some spatial relations (object rotation, I think)

there are probably others

Also, there *IS* a relationship between visual-spatial and testosterone (although many studies said low-T men did *better*). Also some researchers believe that depression affects VS more strongly than verbal.

Donkey Konger's avatar

There was a shape rotation game but they took it down. Pretty sure it was here.

https://rotate-game.herokuapp.com/

Speed's avatar

reminds me of that meme where people on twitter were saying they dont have an internal monologue and that they couldnt visualize shapes in their head

Donkey Konger's avatar

Yeah this was the game at that time

Internal monologue lackers though... not sure about them (unless present company includes those... but i doubt it)

snavehtrebor's avatar

Sitting here trying to think of an F1 race I wouldn't prefer over Vegas... I'll get back to you.

Erik's avatar

We live in an era where it is very easy and popular to cut things down, but few seem to offer a superior alternative. In days gone by, it seems that it was understood the latest and greatest was known to be flawed, but was used until the improved version, or a better technology, came along. Now we just dig in for or against and yell at the opposing side.

It also seems that an IQ test would be the most useful, in a truly compassionate society, to understand which people rank low, so that extra help could be given to them. But that doesn’t seem to be the way the world works.

Btw, kudos to you, Jack, for the Max Zorin reference. It seems most folks have blocked him from their minds.

Midwife Crisis's avatar

"The haters said I couldn't do it. And they were correct. Honestly great call from the haters" - Daniel Ricciardo

Ice Age's avatar

"We told 'em we'd do comedy, and they laughed. But we did it and boy, they're not laughing now!"

- Harold Green

The Red Green Show

Mozzie's avatar

7 Eleven bear claw + cup of coffee + Wednesday thread = another good day at the office

Ice Age's avatar

It's the little things, you know?

Jeff R's avatar

I hadn't considered Suzuka, mostly because flying from the East Coast to Asia is a long miserable slog, but I did similar math with Europe and Canada. If I attend F1 in person, the most likely candidates are Budapest and Montreal. My company has an office in both places, so I might even get some of my travel expenses paid for.

Jeff Madson's avatar

Budapest is the one that I have my eye on for a visit.

Adam 12's avatar

Having been to the city it is wonderful. The food is great and do the Lada car city tour and see the Memorial Park with the Soviet sculptures and hit some of the thermal baths and do a river tour. We missed the race but you will have plenty of other things to do. Wonderful time.

snavehtrebor's avatar

I think Zandvoort would be an absolute blast, but be sure to rent a bicycle that can carry at least 4 Heineken minikegs. Honorable mentions to Austria, Hungary, and any of the Asian races with the exception of China.

unsafe release's avatar

Montreal rocks….no, I mean it; the town literally parties non-stop on GP weekend and the women are breathtakingly gorgeous in their European fashions. Great town, and the race is cool too.

Andy's avatar

True to all that, I've gone to the last two GPs there, and even though the ingress and exit are a bitch, it's a fun circuit to be in.

unsafe release's avatar

Yeah, getting in and out is painful. I’ve had the good fortune of taking the boats down the canal, but the novelty wears off on that pretty quick when it’s pouring rain and there’s not enough cover aboard. You still have to line up coming and going. Last year we figured out a super secret back route that took us down the road where the driver’s road cars are parked. It turned out to be a long walk, but still shorter than waiting in line for the boats.

Ice Age's avatar

I think the ability to discern patterns is WISDOM.

Sherman McCoy's avatar

Important thing about Logan’s race; the Williams pit crew hosed him (at the same time that Yuki’s crew elevated him to the front of that mid pack battle and, ultimately, a points finish).

After that he made an (unforced) error at Degner 2, one of the toughest corners on the calendar. Before he pitted, he was racy within the midfield and driving an assured race.

Jack Baruth's avatar

Well yeah! I was super stoked right up to that moment.

Sherman McCoy's avatar

Had things broken a bit differently, he could’ve been tenth. That would’ve been a great result for him, obviously.

When Alex crashed in Australia, he took over Logan’s chassis. Logan campaigned the repaired (i.e., heavier) chassis in Japan. Logan crashed it pretty heavily in FP1 at Suzuka (bizarre). Alex departed the Grand Prix at Turn 2 courtesy of the Village Idiot.

If Alex’s chassis (Logan’s old chassis) is cracked, will they stand Logan down in China? The spare Williams chassis won’t be ready until Miami at the earliest.

AK47isthetool's avatar

My father, a truly humble man of staggering talents that I have long since given up on approaching living up to, was most proud of mastering the 81mm mortar using the .22 training rounds on the 1:10 range. I think that was all the Army could afford to let them use at the time.

Donkey Konger's avatar

Had to read this twice.

They trained them to use the mortar without mortar rounds?

Jack Baruth's avatar

Honestly it's probably done on a computer now.

Speed's avatar

i wonder if all that time using kentucky windage in battlefield games would transfer over to real life in some respect

Josh Arakes's avatar

When dropping unguided munitions, Kentucky Windage is very much a consideration.

Josh Arakes's avatar

We practice dropping 500lb bombs with 25lb bombs.

The key is to make the ballistics the same.

AK47isthetool's avatar

In the olden days they had an 81mm sabot fired with .22 caliber blanks onto a 1:10 scale range to learn how to calculate the trajectories and whatnnot. So once again, if you have a well above average person do some math, you can teach an average to above average person some math, to allow them to accurately drop explosives on people. And isn't that what it's really all about?

Donkey Konger's avatar

It is what life is all about! A man needs little else for satisfaction in fact

Chuck S's avatar

I kinda want a 1:10 mortar now...

Sir Morris Leyland's avatar

Spud Webb at 5'6" was better at basketball than most 6'6" men.

But if I were captain of an aircraft carrier and had 15 minutes to assemble 10 basketball teams, I'd probably have everyone line up by height and pick the top 50.

IQ is kind of like that.

Jack Baruth's avatar

Now the question is: Can Caitlin Clark, or whatever her name is, shine against the WNBA? Or would she fare better, in the immortal words of Don Imus, against the Toronto Raptors?

Sam's avatar

Based on her play Sunday I'd say she's going to be a solid top 20% player but nothing special. Iowa built a team around her outside shot, but she offered little value in all the other aspects of the sport in that game, little off the ball movement and basically 0 defense. (Note, the national championship game was the only game of hers I watched, perhaps she was not playing her best game)

S2kChris's avatar

As someone who grew up in CT in the 1990s watching UConn men and women’s basketball, I do find the Caitlin spectacle a little interesting. I haven’t sat down and done the spec comparisons, nor do I intend to, but I’d she really more dominant than Rebecca Lobo or Sue Bird or Diana Turasi or others? UConn was so dominant for so long, going undefeated multiple seasons and winning championships, that I don’t know if Clark is that great or it’s just recency bias.

G Jetson's avatar

I think Caitlin has very good basketball IQ (to get back to that topic, eh), sees the court far better than anyone else at the college level. Up there with Lindsay Whalen and Diana Taurasi. I really don't like the women's game generally, but a few players make it worthwhile. I think Caitlin will play better when the pressure is off her to do everything.

Sam's avatar

So did I see a bad showing or am I being too critical of women's game style which I don't watch really any of or did she have a down game?

I went to quite a few UConn games both men and women in the mid to late 00s while I lived in Winstead.

TM's avatar

I’ll give you an example of her basketball IQ. In the semifinal against UCON, Iowa was up two with 3.9 seconds left and had an inbound under their basket. UCON tried to defend the Iowa stack play by putting there tallest player facing the stack with arms spread with her back to Clark who was inbounding the ball. Clark looks around and calmly bounces the inbound pass off the defender’s backside and lets it dribble back out of bounds. It takes the clock to .9 seconds for the next inbound pass so the game is effectively over. That can be a common play in high school but took some nerve and awareness to do it in that situation.

AJS's avatar

She should really consider Ice Cube's $5 million Big3 offer. I don't think she could come close to hanging with even retired NBAers, but, the top salary in the WNBA is (and this isn't a typo) < $250k. As an added bonus, this move could really help prove a point about biological advantage to the side that's full of people who never did anything competitive and coincidentally also see nothing wrong with letting people with dongs entering female MMA or weight lifting events.

TM's avatar

I played pickup ball against a couple of women NC State basketball players when I was living in Raleigh. They both started for a division I team. Neither of them could score on me, ever. I played one year of small college ball. I am 6’2” and could dunk. I was much quicker and faster than them. I was a mediocre player but I think I could take Caitlin Clark in my prime. That is not boasting because I think every player on my high school team could beat her.

AJS's avatar

For sure. The national champion SC team famously prepares by practicing against a men's intramural team.

G Jetson's avatar

I hate to generalize (not really), but it seems like in the women's game, when the women get taller, they really get slow. This is common sense, but it's damn near universal. This same thing happens in the men's game of course, but the men need to be much taller to get as slow. Most of the women over 6' are ploddingly slow, can't jump over 3 inches, and are unwatchable. Maybe the men's game, with many more years in which to mature, has already weeded out the worst big slow guys. Unless they're REALLY big, that is, like good old Zach Edey from Purdue. But even he is more athletic than many female centers in the college game.

yossarian's avatar

i am always seeing these post bragging about ashkenazi jewish iq scores. i think it’s really odd to point out that jews score on average 10 points higher than asians. asia is a very diverse place. how do jewish scores compare to the scores of koreans or the japanese? i bet you it ain’t a big differential. for the record, i’m ashkenazi and i have spent my life getting outsmarted by people who have a lower iq tan me. i think the whole thing is bs.

Sir Morris Leyland's avatar

As a Gentile, I don't know if it is bragging as much as defense against resentment. IQ, combined with a cultural emphasis on education, provides an alternative to nepotism for explaining Jewish overachievement.

Ronnie Schreiber's avatar

As I understand it, northern Asians have higher average IQs than Ashkenazim. I'm about 99% Ashkenazi myself and it doesn't bother me that there are smarter cultures than mine.

Regarding IQ, the joke here in Michigan is "What do Michigan graduates call Michigan State grads?" Boss.

yossarian's avatar

never heard that one but it reminds me of this one: "a" students work for "b" students in companies founded by "c" students.

yossarian's avatar

i'd like to add that i logged back on to delete my comment because i thought it was obnoxious and possibly humble bragging. but i was so impressed with the responses that i've decided to leave it.

Harry's avatar

It is impossible to both talk about your intelligence and be polite. You have to either brag, humblebrag, or self deprecate, and it it still feels awkward.

Speed's avatar

iq is like dick size

if yours is bigger they hate you

if its smaller they mock you

and 99% of the time nobody asked anyway

Hex168's avatar

Agreed. I did it anyway here, but if it wasn't here I would not have done it at all. That's a compliment, folks.

Sherman McCoy's avatar

Here’s a question for the hivemind:

Jack is on record with his belief that wearing a Rolex Daytona is cringe, unless you “earned” the watch by winning in class at the Rolex 24 at Daytona (sponsorship agreement began in the early ‘90s) or, presumably, by winning overall at Le Mans (only the overall winner “earns” a Daytona at Le Mans).

Mark Webber conducts podium interviews for Formula 1 from time to time; predictably, he did so recently in Australia. He is a Rolex “testimonee” (i.e., spokesperson) like Jackie Stewart. Neither of them have ever won Daytona or Le Mans; so what do they think they are doing prancing around with a Cosmograph on their wrist??

NB - I don’t necessarily agree with this belief, but it’s not a big deal to me. I owned, enjoyed, and eventually sold a Daytona.

On a similar “stolen valor” tangent:

I think it’s downright pathetic for someone who is not a member of Augusta National to wear any branded Masters - or, even worse, Augusta National - merchandise.

S2kChris's avatar

Given the flex that is getting Masters tickets I would argue that if you’ve been to ANGC, you can wear the merch.

To say otherwise is like saying if you aren’t an owner or otherwise staff of the Red Sox, or haven’t played a game on Fenway Park field, you can’t wear Red Sox merch.

We don’t need to go through life gatekeeping everything.

I would also not presume to tell Mark Webber, or especially Jackie Stewart, what they can and can’t do.

Sherman McCoy's avatar

That’s the crux of it:

I don’t think going to the Masters is a flex; wearing the merch illustrates that the wearer thinks it IS a flex.

Being a member is a flex, but very few of the members would ever flex about it - both because they don’t need to, and because they know it would be seen as tacky (by their peers).

E.g. - this guy: https://www.monarchprivate.com/team-members/turner-simkins/

His bio lists a number of affiliations, memberships, etc. He is an Augusta National member, but he would never put that in his bio. It *might* be in his obituary.

S2kChris's avatar

You may not think going to the Masters is a flex, but it is the most desirable ticket in one of the US’s most prominent sports. I would have a hard time choosing between tickets to the Masters, Super Bowl, and Final Four/National Championship game for men’s college bball. I’d take Master’s tickets hands down over World Series or NBA finals or Stanley Cup tickets, no question. I would happily wear a shirt or hat from the Masters, and be happy to tell anyone who didn’t like it they can fuck off.

Sherman McCoy's avatar

At an absolute minimum, you would need to have played the course to wear the merch.

Adam 12's avatar

I have never been impressed by what one wears, but understand it is a symbol. Now if you have qualified for the Boston Marathon or an ultramarathon in your age you have my respect. (Not talking about people who qualify for a charity spot or an athletic company spot).

Sherman McCoy's avatar

Another example is the Mount Gay Rum sailing hat.

Ronnie Schreiber's avatar

More rules than the *Shulchan Aruch. How do you keep track of them all?

*For the culturally uninformed, that's the Code of Jewish Law by R' Yoseph Caro.

Jack Baruth's avatar

For purposes of clarification:

What I said was that a Daytona should not be worn by any driver who might at some point in his career be in, or adjacent to, the chance to win one.

If non-competitive people on the street want to wear a Daytona, more power to them. If a Lemons racer wants to... who cares. But if I go to an SCCA or IMSA race and see a Daytona on your wrist, I'm gonna ask you what year you won it.

The equivalent I think in cycling is the maillot jeune. I could wear a yellow jersey while riding road. But if a Cat 1 rider wears it without earning it, they're gonna get hassled.

Yeah, this is gatekeeping, but you gotta be in the club for it to apply to you. I don't walk around a restaurant at dinner and complain that people have the nerve to wear a Daytona.

Sherman McCoy's avatar

There is a lot of mystique surrounding the Daytona, whether from car / motorsports people or people who are entirely unaware of the racing connection.

The Daytona seemed a lot less special to me after I bought a Royal Oak. The Daytona bracelet is simply the Oyster bracelet (i.e., the same as the Submariner, etc.) with polished center links. Rolex’s best bracelet is the Jubliee, imo. The Daytona case is very similar to that of the other Rolex sport models, the dial is fairly illegible, the chronograph functionality robs you of the large sweeping second hand (unless you have the chrono running), there’s no date window, etc.

Jack Baruth's avatar

Learning too much about ANY watch will disabuse you of envy for it.

Pretty much every Swiss watch out there looks like dogshit under a microscope compared to a Grand Seiko Spring Drive.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 11, 2024
Comment deleted
Sherman McCoy's avatar

Would you extend that claim to Holy Trinity or similar (e.g., Lange) watches?

I’ve never examined a Grand Seiko up close; a friend of mine has one, but he rarely wears it.

Jim K's avatar

I am usually a few days behind in catching up with all my ACF comments, so this will most likely get buried, but had to contribute to a watch related discussion.

GS and Seiko (medium - high end) are so underrated, many times within the watch enthusiasts world, much less the general "watch aware" public.

Last December, I bought a Seiko SPB143 for my college age son. He expressed an interest in his first nice watch, so I set myself a budget of $1000. I ordered the watch from a local AD in the Atlanta area, and got it for $972 out the door with tax. Fantastic watch and quality for the money, great value. He loves it.

I was so impressed with the SPB143 I ended up purchasing a Seiko SJE093 (one of the many "reissues" of the Seiko's first 62MAS diver) for myself. I don't like Seiko's practice of limited editions etc. but I've always wanted a Seiko diver this size (38mm and < 13mm thick), and I'm a sucker for the vintage skin diver style and size.

I have owned many high end swiss watches and the first time I was in a GS shop, I was very, very impressed with the quality and finishing. Styling and size don't suit me, but very impressive watches.

Jim K's avatar

Tried on the AP RO 15550 recently at the Atlanta AD. The bracelet and dial are absolutely special. If it wasn't for inability to get the 15550 at retail and social media stigma of AP these days, I would absolutely be saving my pennies for the RO.

Sherman McCoy's avatar

I always say that APs, particularly Royal Oaks and Code 11:59s, need to be seen in person, ideally on your wrist, to appreciate them. The bracelet really makes the watch.

Be patient - prices continue to trend back toward earth, and I think you will be able to secure what you want either at retail from an AD or in the secondary market with an acceptable premium to MSRP (and no sales tax).

I agree with the social media stigma comment - I’d rather they were not so polarizing.

Finally, it is my understanding that the Atlanta AP / Watches of Switzerland boutique will be closing imminently. It opened during summer of 2019, so perhaps it was a five year commitment / lease.

Ataraxis's avatar

My buddies have a tournament every year where the winner gets a really bad green sport coat that was bought at Goodwill. They get much drunker than the real Masters’ winner, so there is achievement involved.

Sherman McCoy's avatar

The green jackets themselves are hideous.

Ice Age's avatar

"I believe that's Mr. Gilmore's jacket!"

Mike O's avatar

Ataraxis, on a completely unrelated note, did you recently make a comment on Wirepoints?

Ataraxis's avatar

I’ve been known to comment there.

Mike O's avatar

Probably have seen other comments you have made. Liked the one from yesterday so much actually noticed who made it. I'm a little slow sometimes.

Chuck S's avatar

Jackie Stewart was a three-time world champion and two-time runner-up at a time when men regularly died in horrific crashes, and he fought to make the sport safer for all.

Mark Webber's car went airborne, flipped lengthwise, slid on its roll hoop, then flipped back over and went into the tire barrier in a 190 mph crash during the 2010 European Grand Prix and he walked away.

Both men can line Daytonas up the length of their arms like 80s kids wearing Swatches. They've earned the right to do whatever the fuck they want.

Sherman McCoy's avatar

That was mostly a dig at Jack’s philosophy.

Neither of them need lower themselves to the level of a candy-ass BOP series like IMSA; I say that as someone who has paid out of pocket to attend 40+ IMSA race weekends.

Chuck S's avatar

I always interpreted Jack's position as referring to wanna-be drivers, not guys who have actually gone wheel-to-wheel at truly dangerous speeds with any level of skill and talent.

I can't imagine him looking askance at Webber for wearing a Daytona. Now if it were a Monaco, that's another story...

Jack Baruth's avatar

Webber gets paid to wear a Daytona, which is why he wears it. If you work for Rolex, you're going to wear a Rolex.

He's certainly a better driver than I am, although he was lucky to have Vettel as a standard of comparison instead of say, one M. Verstappen, who would have lapped him in every race.

Sherman McCoy's avatar

Verstappen wears a Monaco … because he’s paid to.

Thomas's avatar

Wearing a Daytona without having won at Daytona is the same as wearing a Submariner (or Seadweller) and not being a deep sea diver, or wearing a Skydweller and not being a pilot.

In other words, nobody cares.

Sherman McCoy's avatar

No one should wear a Skydweller for any reason!

Thomas's avatar

Okay, what about an Air King*?

* nobody wants those either

Sherman McCoy's avatar

The Skydweller is an elaborate prank perpetrated upon everyone with eyes.