Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jack Baruth's avatar

The unforgiveable sin of the two FWD Cadillac platforms during the Eighties wasn't size, really -- it's the same size as a BMW 528e, almost exactly! - but PROPORTION. General Motors was so determined to pull off a SECOND interior-size miracle after the 1977 downsizing that they absolutely failed to realize how odd a 1977-spacious interior would look on a car that was 33 inches shorter. It looks like a four-door pod with a little vestigial nose and tail, like the kei trucks that everybody loves now.

Had they given it BMW interior space and BMW proportions, it would have done just fine.

Erik's avatar

There is no such thing as a “really nice ‘86 Elegante”. I’m a huge Cadillac nut, and yes I drive an XTS daily, but the 86 Seville was a bridge too far for me. I’m more forgiving of the Cimarron than those things. The fine folks at Cadillac couldn’t really do much with the Cimarron, but the Seville was all their fault. And yes, the hippies are right that it looks like an expanded Sommerset. Yes, by 1989 it was a dramatically better car, but it was a styling dud all along.

15 more comments...

Ready for more?